Shutter island case study

A film that will divide the film community. A film that will leave many upset, and hating it. A film that has already completely split the critics.

Shutter island case study

Shutter island case study

Psychoanalysis and Behaviorism are two opposite perspectives, yet similar techniques are used in treating this disorder to integrate all personalities into one. Even though the perspectives are accused of being either too scientific or not falsifiable, a merge of both orientations can be of great help to a person suffering from DID to a certain extent.

Rachel was admitted after drowning her three children for no apparent reason but she left behind a note: The Law of 4 Who is 67? A reformed alcoholic, haunted by the memories of his deceased wife and World War II visions, Teddy states that he chose this assignment to find Andrew Laeddis, the man who set fire to his apartment, subsequently killing his wife, Dolores Chanal; he believes Laeddis is in Ward C, which is where the most dangerous criminals are kept.

Teddy starts to become paranoid that everyone on the island is hiding something, suspecting Nazi experiments on the brain are being conducted.

As Teddy tries to uncover the truth behind his conspiracy, he comes to realize that he is actually Andrew Laeddis and is a patient in the asylum, admitted after murdering his bipolar wife two years ago after she drowned their children.

Sheehan Chuck and Dr. Cawley conducted in a desperate attempt to integrate his personalities to prevent a lobotomy from taking place. The diagnosis also includes amnesia as a symptom, as several patients suffering this disorder have memory loss of significant life experiences.

The DSM states generally that dissociation is a way of a person to escape a traumatic event and allows them to disregard what is happening to them. What influences our behavior can be found in our unconscious, which is a collection of feelings, thoughts, urges, and memories that have been placed outside our awareness, as our mind finds them unacceptable or unpleasant.

Sigmund Freud, the father of Psychoanalysis, stated that we have two primitive drives that motivate our behavior and thoughts: Eros life and Thanatos death.


The life instinct serves to bring life and an increase in tension while the death instinct serves to move towards death and self- destruction. These survival instincts help us stay alive, procreate, and prevent others from taking our needs away and it also helps compose our three elements of personality: If not met, the person will result in a state of anxiety or tension.

The final component is the superego, which holds all moral, cultural, and social standards we have acquired and internalized and it is in constant struggle with the id. In an unhealthy person, the ego would not be the strongest component and the person would be under the control of either its id or superego, leading to several dysfunctional behaviors.

In terms of childhood development, Psychoanalysis argues that there is a window between 18 months-5 years where there is the highest possibility to develop DID because the separation between self, abstract, and 2 Reham Al Taher Student id: There is also the use of more defense mechanisms since the sequence of abusive experiences matched with the available defenses a child can use at that time may lead to internal structural differences, different alters, and can posses different skills with each alter.

Not only do thoughts manifest through our behavior but through dreams as well, as is shown with Teddy. It should be noted that Freud discussed two levels of dream content: The manifest content, which includes the actual images and thoughts contained in the dream and the latent content, which is the hidden underlying symbolic meaning of the dream.

There are two significant dreams throughout the film that illustrate the unpleasant thoughts his conscious cannot bear to face.

The first dream was his wife, Dolores, telling Teddy that Laeddis and Solondo are still on the island. As she looks at the lake through her window, her back starts to bleed and she turns slowly into ashes. The room slowly starts to catch fire as Teddy looks down at his pouring wet hands.

The manifest content is that Teddy misses his wife and wishes she never died; the latent content reveal the hidden meaning of the symbols. Dolores bleeds as she looks at the lake his children drowned in, symbolizing his drained emotions from guilt.

The final symbol shown is water, a large lake and it dripping from his fingertips. Freud stated that large bodies of water represent our unconscious mind but it also had sexual connotations to it. The second dream finds itself with the same prior symbols but it has been extended to others.

He first finds himself at the Dachau concentration camp, where he sees Solondo and his daughter lying with a pile of bodies. He then comes face to face with his version of Laeddisa malevolent looking character trying to tempt him with his flask before Rachel Solondo appears once again.

This 3 Reham Al Taher Student id: As Freud believed we are essentially every character in our dreams, his dead wife and children may be an extended representation of himself that has crippled him with guilt and he tries to drown his children deeper into his unconscious to avoid attaching himself to the crime.

The motive behind this shift is so the person can exist in as many parts as necessary to gratify his life and death instincts. The defenses are not simply mechanisms, they have evolved into elaborate fantasies the patient uses to cope and prevent anxiety-provoking stimuli.Shutter Island is no impenetrable art-house enigma: it's an old-fashioned noirish thriller that ends with a massive plot twist.

As such, you might have thought it would have been easy to understand. Shutter Island study guide contains a biography of Dennis Lehane, literature essays, quiz questions, major themes, characters, and a full summary and analysis. About Shutter Island Shutter Island .

Case study Shutter Island 1. Case Study- Shutter Island i ShutterIslandisa psychological Thrillerfilm, directedby Martin Scorsese and writtenbyLaeta attheheels.comoducedby ParamountPictures,Phoenix was filmedinthe USA,and releasedon12th March (UK).The filmhasgrossedan estimate total of $ million, makingit Scorsese’smostsuccessful filmyet.

Shutter Island: Psychoanalysis of Andrew Laeddis Martin Scorsese’s Shutter Island is a movie that follows a psychiatric patient in the ’s. The psychiatric facility called Ashecliffe Hospital is located on Shutter Island, and it provides psychiatric care for the criminally insane%(1).

Shutter Island Case Study: Teddy Daniels/Andrew Laeddis Brief Summary Teddy Daniels, also known as, Andrew Laeddis, played by Leonardo DiCaprio, in the film Shutter Island is the character being reviewed in this case study.

Shutter island case study

Case study- Shutter Island 1. Case Study- Shutter Island i ShutterIslandisa psychological Thrillerfilm, directedby Martin Scorsese and writtenbyLaeta attheheels.comoducedby ParamountPictures,Phoenix was filmedinthe USA,and releasedon12th March (UK).The filmhasgrossedan estimate total of $ million, makingit Scorsese’smostsuccessful filmyet.

AS Media Studies Blog: Shutter Island Case Study